Later reviews skip what an Update branch merge brought in, and one misplaced comment no longer unseats the rest
A review of the commits since the last one looked at everything those commits changed, and a merge from the base branch (GitHub's Update branch button) changes lines that are not the pull request's. Those lines were reviewed, paid for, and flagged; a comment on one made GitHub reject the whole review, so every finding fell into the review body with no thread to reply in or resolve. Later reviews now cover only the pull request's own hunks the new commits touched.
Before posting, each finding's lines are checked against the pull request's diff. One that sits outside it is listed in the review body on its own; the others are posted as comments as usual, with replies and Resolved working on each.
More in Incremental review.